Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of the animal studies eligible for this review

From: Mitochondrial transplantation therapy for ischemia reperfusion injury: a systematic review of animal and human studies

Species

Type of model

Target Organ

Source of mitochondria

Transplantation method, dose, and timing

Randomization

Blinded assessment

Main outcomes

Refs

C57BL6 mice

(male)

Focal ischemia

(MCAO)

Brain

Allograft:

Placenta

IV, 100 μg, Immediately after

Reperfusion

Yes

Yes

Decreased infarct size 72 h post-ischemia

[25]

Wistar rat

Focal ischemia (MCAO)

Brain

Xenograft:

hUC-MSCs

Direct ICVs, 10 μL of healthy mitochondria isolated from 3 × 107 MSCs, After reperfusion (within 10 min)

Not reported

Not reported

Reduced Infarct size 72 h after ischemia;

Improved motor function after 24 h

[31]

SD rat

(male)

Focal ischemia (MCAO)

Brain

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

Direct ICVs, 5 × 106, Immediately after reperfusion

Yes

Yes

Improved motor functions after MCAO, with reduced infarct volume and apoptosis

[32]

SD rats

(male)

Focal ischemia

(MCAO)

Brain

Xenograft:

BHK-21 cells

Direct IC, 75 μg or IA (femoral), 750 μg,

24 h post-MCAO

Not reported

Not reported

IC and IA reduced infarct size 4 weeks post-ischemia and improved functional rotarod and grip strength performance for up to 1-month post-transplantation

[33]

1) bEnd3 and PC12 cell

2) C57BL6 mice

(male)

1) OGD,

2) TBI

1) Cell,

2) Brain

Allograft:

BDMts

1) Co-culture

2) IC into the ipsilateral cortex, 1.1 × 107 mitochondria/μL × 10 μL,

10 min post-TBI

Yes

Yes

1) In vitro: improved cellular respiration and synaptic plasticity

2) In vivo: Reduced apoptosis, BBB damage, and brain edema

[30]

Yorkshire pigs

(female)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

IA (coronary), 1 × 109,

120 min after reperfusion

Yes

Not reported

Reduced myocardial infarct size and enhanced regional and global myocardial function post-reperfusion

[34]

Yorkshire Pigs

(female)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

Subendocardial injection 8 times, 1.3 × 107 mitochondria per injection site, 1 min before reperfusion

Yes

Not reported

No change in inflammatory and cytokine activation markers; decreased infarct size but no change in global function

[36]

Yorkshire swine (female)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

IA (coronary), 1 × 109,

Immediately on reperfusion

Not reported

No

Improved myocardial function, perfusion, and infarct size

[37]

Yorkshire Pigs

(female)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

Single IA (coronary): 1 × 109, 15 min before regional ischemia

Serial IA (coronary): 1 × 109 mitochondria × 10 injections, Every 5 min since 60 min before ischemia

Yes

Yes

Reduced myocardial infarct size, improved myocardial function;

no difference between single and serial injections

[38]

New Zealand White rabbits (female)

1) Image study:

Global or regional ischemia

2) Function study;

regional ischemia

Heart

1) Xenograft:

Human cardiac fibroblasts

2) Autograft:

Liver

2) IA (coronary), 1 × 108,

Upon reperfusion

Not reported

Yes

1) Mitochondria were observed in interstitial spaces, associated with blood vessels, and cardiomyocytes

2) Reduced infarct size and enhanced myocardial function

[39]

New Zealand white rabbits (male)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

Direct injection 8 times, 1.2 × 106 per injection site, 1 min before reperfusion

Not reported

Yes

Reduced myocardial infarct size and enhanced regional myocardial function post-reperfusion

[40]

C57BL/6 J mice (male)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Allograft:

Gastrocnemius muscle

IA (coronary), 1 × 108,10 min before organ harvest and 5 min after transplantation

Not reported

Yes

Enhanced graft function and decreased graft tissue injury

[41]

C57BL/6 mice (male)

Focal ischemia

Heart

Not reported

Direct injection at myocardium of the left ventricle, 5 × 104,

During 24 h perfusion at 4 different points

Not reported

Not reported

Mitochondrial transplantation inhibited cardiomyocyte apoptosis in vitro

In vivo transplantation of Alda-1-treated mitochondria limited infarction size after I/R injury

[42]

Yorkshire pigs (female)

Global ischemia

Heart

1) 1st, Autograft: Pectoralis major muscle

2) 2nd, Allograft: swine cardiac fibroblast cell

IA (coronary), 5 × 109,

1) 15 min post-reperfusion

2) 2 h post-reperfusion

Yes

Yes

Preserved myocardial function and oxygen consumption and, decreased infarct size

[35]

Wistar rats (male)

Focal ischemia

Kidney

Autograft:

Pectoralis major muscle

IA (renal), 7.5 × 106, 5 min before reperfusion

Not reported

Not reported

Increased renal function, renal cell repair, and proliferation capacity

[43]

Yorkshire pigs (female)

Focal ischemia

Kidney

Autograft: Sternocleidomastoid muscle

Single IA (renal artery), 1 × 109,

Immediately at reperfusion

Yes

Yes

No safety issues detected

Increased GFR and urine output, decreased serum creatinine and BUN

[44]

C57BL/6 J mice (male)

Focal ischemia

Hindlimb

Allograft:

Muscle

Direct injection, 1 × 106–1 × 109 per gram muscle wet weight, 15 min after reperfusion

Not reported

Yes

Decreased infarct size and apoptosis; improved hindlimb function

[45]

C57BL/6 J mice (male)

Focal ischemia

Lung

Allograft: Gastrocnemius muscle

IA (pulmonary), 1 × 108, or Aerosol delivery to whole lung by nebulization, 3 × 108,

Immediately at reperfusion

Yes

Yes

Both delivery methods improved lung mechanics and decreased

lung tissue injury

[46]

SD rats

(male)

Focal ischemia

Spinal cord

Allograft:

Soleus muscle

IV (jugular), 100 μg,

5 min before reperfusion

Yes

Yes

Attenuated inflammatory, ER stress, and neuro-apoptotic reactions

Improvement in motor function

[47]

SD rats

(male)

Focal ischemia

Liver

Allograft:

Liver

Portal vein, 10 mg,

Upon reperfusion

Yes

Not reported

31P-MRS showed that the hepatic levels of ATP and NADH were higher in the m-Mito group than in the IRI group. The m-Mito group decreased the liver injury score and inflammatory cell infiltration in liver compared to the IRI group

[48]

  1. SD, Sprague–Dawley; hUC-MSCs, human umbilical cord derived mesenchymal stem cells; MCAO, middle cerebral artery occusion; OGD, glucose oxygen deprivation; TBI, traumatic brain injury; BHK-21, Baby hamster kidney fibroblast; BDMt, brain-derived mitochondria; ICV, intracerebroventricular injection; IC, intracerebral injection; IA, intra-arterial injection; BBB, blood brain barrier; GFR, glomerular filtration rate; BUN, blood urea nitrogen; ER, endoplasmic reticulum; IRI, ischemia reperfusion injury; 31P-MRS, 31P-magnetic resonance spectroscopy; m-Mito, melatonin pretreated-mitochondrial transplantation