Skip to main content

Table 1 Diagnostic criteria classification with respect to the significance of PEM and other core symptoms

From: The evidence base for physiotherapy in myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome when considering post-exertional malaise: a systematic review and narrative synthesis

Criteria set ME/CFS

Post-exertional malaise inclusion

 

Author/institution

No PEM (CF)

Optional PEM (CFS)

Required PEM (ME)

CDC (1988), Holmes definition

Holmes 1988 [53], Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, USA

 

X

 

Oxford (1991)

Sharpe 1991 [22]

X

  

CDC (1994), Fukuda definition

Fukuda 1994 [23], Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

 

X

 

London (1994)

The National Task Force on CFS/PVFS/ME 1994 [54]

 

Xa

 

CCC (2003), Canadian Consensus Criteria for ME/CFS

Carruthers 2003 [24]

  

X

Empirical CDC (2005)

Reeves 2005 [55], Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, USA

 

X

 

NICE guideline (2007)

Nice 2007 [56], UK’s National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence

 

Xb

 

Canada-revised (2010)

Jason 2010 [57]

  

X

ME-ICC (2011), International Consensus Criteria for ME

Carruthers 2011 [25]

  

Xc

IOM (2015) (SEID)

Institute of Medicine 2015 [1]

  

X

  1. aRequires exercise-induced fatigue, but does not require presence of all core symptoms;
  2. bNo PEM required (may be post-exertional fatigue) and does not require presence of all core symptoms;
  3. cPost-exertional neuroimmune exhaustion (PENE)