Setting (N of studies) | First Author/Year of publish/(reference) | Main focus | Interventiona | Study typeb | Country/name of program | Increase of PAc | Sessiond | Total sample (IN, CN) | Duration (year) | Range of age | Follow-up (year)e | Frequency of intervention | Target group | Quality scoref | g↓ in BMI | g↓ in BMI-Z |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
School (n = 25) | Wang/2018 [22] | PA | 2 | 1 | China/YOG-Obesity study | NR | NR | 9858 (5275, 4583) | 1 | 9–12 | 0h | W | Children | 1 | ✔ | ✔ |
Leme/2018 [23] (two individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 0 | 1 | Brazil/H3G-Brazil | NR | 60 | 253 (412, 111) | 0.5 | 14–18 | 0, 0.5 | M | Children and parents | 3 | – | – | |
Lubans/2016 [24] (two individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | Australia/ATLAS | 26 | 3 | 361 (181, 180) | 0.66 | 12–14 | 0, 0.84 | W | Children | 1 | – | – | |
Hollis/2016 [25] (two individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | Australia/PA4E1 | 70,156 | 288 | 1150 (645, 505) | 1, 2 | 10–11 | 0 | W | Children | 2 | ✔ | ✔ | |
Smith/2014 [26] | PA | 2 | 1 | Australia/ATLAS | 18 | 1.5 | 361 (181, 180) | 0.41 | 12–14 | 0.25 | W | Children | 2 | – | j | |
Lubans/2012 [27] | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | Australia/NEAT Girl | 91.5 | 4.6 | 357 (178, 179) | 1 | 12–14 | 0 | W | Children | 1 | – | – | |
Millar/2011 [28] | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | Australia/IYM | NR | NR | 2054 (1276, 778) | 1 | 12–18 | 1.3 | D | Children | 1 | ✔ | ✔ | |
Llargues/2011 [29] | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | US/AVall | NR | 288 | 509 (272, 237) | 2 | 5–6 | 0 | W | Children | 1 | – | j | |
Salcedo Aguilar/2010 [30] (four individual study due to sex and duration) | PA | 2 | 1 | New Zealand/MOVI | 234,468 | 126 | 921 (375, 546) | 1, 1.66 | 9–10 | 0 | W | Children | 1 | – | j | |
Neumark-Sztainer/2010 [31] (two individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | US/New Moves | 32 | 27.33 | 356 (182, 147) | 0.33 | 14–189 | 0, 0.41 | W | Children | 1 | – | j | |
Group/2010 [32] | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | US/school-based program on risk factors for DM | NR | NR | 4603 (2307, 2296) | 2 | 11–12 | 0 | NR | Children | 3 | i | ✔ | |
Dzewaltowski/2010 [33] | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | US/HOP’N | 215 | 240 | 273 (148, 125) | 2 | 9–10 | 0 | D | Children | 3 | – | – | |
Donnelly/2009 [34] | PA | 2 | 1 | US/PAAC | 234 | NR | 1527 (814, 713) | 3 | 6–9 | 0 | W | Children | 1 | – | j | |
Taylor/2008 [35] (two individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 2 | 2 | New Zealand/APPLE | NR | NR | 727 (381, 346) | 1 | 6–11 | 0, 1.8 | D | Children | 3 | NRk | ✔ | |
Martínez Vizcaíno /2008 [36] (two individual study due to sex) | PA | 2 | 1 | Spain/Movi | 108 | NR | 1119 (513, 579) | 0.5 | 9–10 | 0 | W | Children | 2 | – | j | |
Foster/2008 [37] | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | US/SNPI | NR | 180 | 1349 (749, 600) | 2 | 9–12 | 0 | W | Children | 2 | i | – | |
Community, school (n = 14) | Bell/2019 [38] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Australia/OPAL | NR | NR | 2353 (1208, 1145) | 5 | 0–18 | 0 | D | Children and parents | 3 | – | j |
Santiago Felipe/2018 [39] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Spain/TCHP | NR | 30 | 2086 (974, 112) | 1.25 | 8–10 | 0 | W | Children and parents | 3 | – | ||
Novotny/2018 [40] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | US/Children’s Healthy Living Program | NR | NR | 1882 (952, 930) | 2 | 2–8 | 0 | NR | Children | 2 | i | – | |
Adab/2018 [41] (three individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 1 | 1 | UK/WAVES | 45 | 21 | 1392 (660, 732) | 1 | 6–7 | 0.25, 1.5, 2.25 | D | Children | 3 | i | – | |
Sadeghi/2017 [42] (two individual study due to sex) | Diet + PA | 0 | 1 | US/NSFS | 10.4 | NR | 422 (271, 151) | 3 | 3–8 | 1 | W | Children | 1 | i | – | |
Swinburn/2014 [43] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Australia/BAEW | NR | NR | 1674 (877, 797) | 3 | 10–12 | 0 | D | Children | 1 | – | – | |
Pettman/2014 [44] (two individual study due to age groups) | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Australia/ewba | NR | NR | 2631 (1300, 1331) | 3 | 4–5, 10–12 | 0 | NR | Children | 2 | – | – | |
Kremer/2011 [45] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Fiji/HYHC | NR | NR | 2968 (879, 2069) | 1.75 | 13–18 | 0 | NR | Children | 2 | – | – | |
Fotu/2011 [46] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Tonga/MYP | NR | NR | 1712 (815, 897) | 2.4 | 11–19 | 0 | NR | Children and parents | 3 | – | – | |
Sanigorski/2008 [47] | Diet + PA | 3 | 2 | Australia/BAEW | NR | NR | 3688 (1001, 2687) | 3 | 4–12 | 0 | D | Children | 2 | – | ✔ | |
School, home (n = 2) | Romon/2009 {48] (two individual study due to sex) | Diet + PA | 2 | 2 | France/FLVS | NR | NR | 1502 (804, 698) | 12 | 5–12 | 0 | NR | Children | 1 | ✔ | j |
Community, school, home (n = 5) | Crespo/2012 [49] (three individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | US/APN | NR | 22 | 392 (165, 227) | 1 | 5–7 | 0, 1, 2 | NR | Children | 3 | i | – |
Gentile/2009 [50] (two individual study due to duration) | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | US/ Switch& what you Do, View, and Chew | NR | NR | 1323 (670, 653) | 6,12 | 6–11 | 0 | NR | Children | 2 | – | j | |
Community, school, home, primary care clinic (n = 12) | Economos CD /2007 [51] (four individual study due to community and sex) | Diet + PA | 3 | 2 | US/SUS | 40 | 16 | 1178 (385, 793) | 0.66 | 6–8 | 0 | W | Children and parents and teachers and policy makers | 2 | i | ✔ |
Wong/2016 [52] (three individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 2 | 1 | US/Healthy Kids Houston | NR | NR | 877 (524, 353) | 0.125, 0.25, 0.375 | 9–12 | 0, 0.125, 0.25 | W | Children | 1 | – | – | |
Johnson/2012 [5]) | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Australia/BAEW | NR | NR | 2905 (1726, 1183) | 3 | 4–12 | 0 | NR | Children | 3 | NRk | ✔ | |
de Silva-Sanigorski /2010 [54] (two individual study due to age groups) | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | Australia/Romp and Chomp | NR | NR | 35,157 (2778, 32,379) | 3 | 0–5 | 3 | D | Children | 1 | ✔ (only in 2 years old) | ✔ (only in 2 years old) | |
Taylor/2007 [55] (two individual study due to duration) | Diet + PA | 3 | 2 | New Zealand/APPLE | NR | NR | 470 (251, 219) | 1,2 | 5–12 | 0 | NR | Children | 1 | – | ✔ | |
Community, home (n = 3) | de Henauw/2015 [56] (two individual study due to sex) | Diet + PA | 3 | 2 | 8 European countries/IDEFICS | NR | NR | 16,228 (4882, 7746) | 0.58 | 2–9.9 | 1.42 | NR | Children and parents | 1 | i | ✔ (in girls) |
Elder /2014 [57] | Diet + PA | 3 | 1 | US/MOVE | NR | 36.6 | 541 (271, 270) | 2 | 10–14 | 0 | W | Parent | 3 | – | – | |
Primary care clinic (n = 1) | Eno Persson/2018 [58] | Diet + PA | 0 | 2 | Sweden/PRIMROSE | NR | NR | 1030 (431, 599) | 3.25 | 0.75–5 | 1 | NR | Parent | 3 | – | j |
Cyberspace (n = 2) | Hammersley/2019 [59] (two individual study due to follow up) | Diet + PA | 0 | 1 | Australia/Time2bHealthy | NR | NR | 86 (42, 44) | 0.5 | 2–5 | 0.25, 0.5 | M | Parent | 3 | – | j |